Home » How to Make Café de Olla at Home

How to Make Café de Olla at Home

Jacob Yaze

August 2, 2026

OneHundredCoffee is reader-supported, and some products displayed may earn us an affiliate commission. Details

Café de Olla is one of those coffee recipes that feels comforting before you even take the first sip. It is warm, spiced, lightly sweet, aromatic, and deeply connected to Mexican home cooking. Instead of tasting like plain brewed coffee with sugar added afterward, Café de Olla tastes integrated. The cinnamon, piloncillo, cloves, orange peel, and coffee simmer together so the final cup feels rounded and fragrant.

The name “Café de Olla” means “coffee from the pot,” and traditionally it is prepared in a clay pot called an “olla de barro. The clay pot can add an earthy, rustic warmth to the drink, but you do not need one to make a beautiful version at home. A small saucepan works perfectly. What matters most is the balance: good coffee, real cinnamon, dark unrefined sugar, gentle spices, and enough steeping time for everything to come together.

As we discussed before in Coffee Origins 101, origin and roast level can change the whole personality of a cup. For Café de Olla, I prefer a medium or medium-dark coffee with chocolate, nutty, caramel, or brown sugar notes. Mexican coffee is a natural fit if you have it, but Colombian, Guatemalan, Brazilian, or other smooth medium roasts can also work well.

This is not a delicate pour-over recipe. It is cozy, rustic, and deeply aromatic — the kind of coffee that makes the kitchen smell like cinnamon and warm sugar.

Best Coffee Beans for Coffee De Olla Recipes — At a Glance

Image	Product	Features	Price
Best Spiced Depth	Peet’s Major Dickason’s Whole Bean	Bold dark roast Dark roast richness Strong cinnamon base Molasses-like depth Great piloncillo match	Price on Amazon
Best Rich Spice	Lavazza Gran Riserva Whole Bean	Full-bodied espresso roast Deep roast body Spice-friendly profile Rich chocolate finish Strong brewed flavor	Price on Amazon
Best Smooth Olla	Lavazza Super Crema Whole Bean	Creamy nutty balance Medium espresso roast Mild brown sweetness Smooth spice pairing Gentle cinnamon finish	Price on Amazon
Best Organic Medium	Kicking Horse Three Sisters Whole Bean	Cocoa fruit balance Organic whole beans Medium roast profile Cocoa sweetness Good clove pairing	Price on Amazon
Best Gentle Spice	illy Classico Whole Bean	Caramel floral smoothness 100% Arabica blend Medium roast balance Caramel-like cup Soft spice finish	Price on Amazon
Best Aromatic Base	Lavazza Espresso Italiano Whole Bean	Sweet Arabica profile 100% Arabica beans Floral-fruity notes Medium roast smoothness Good panela pairing	Price on Amazon
Best Chocolate Spice	Stumptown Hair Bender Whole Bean	Citrus chocolate depth Medium roast beans Dark chocolate finish Bright spice lift Rich brewed cup	Price on Amazon
Best Light Spice	Starbucks Blonde Espresso Whole Bean	Mellow sweet cup Blonde roast profile Soft sweetness Less bitter taste Gentle cinnamon base	Price on Amazon
Best Honey Spice	Lavazza Espresso Barista Gran Crema	Honeyed espresso body Full-bodied espresso Honey aromatic note Rich warm texture Balanced spiced sweetness	Price on Amazon
Best Sweet Specialty	Intelligentsia Black Cat Classic Espresso	Syrupy balanced espresso Light roast espresso Sweet cup structure Clean spice contrast Elegant olla finish	Price on Amazon

What Is Café de Olla?

Café de Olla is a traditional Mexican spiced coffee usually made with ground coffee, cinnamon, piloncillo, and water. Many versions also include cloves, star anise, orange peel, or other warming spices. The ingredients are simmered or steeped together, then strained and served hot.

The drink is often associated with rural kitchens, family gatherings, cold mornings, and traditional Mexican cooking. It is not meant to taste like a modern flavored latte. It is simpler and more earthy. The sweetness comes from piloncillo, which has a deep molasses-like flavor. The cinnamon gives warmth. The coffee gives body and bitterness. The optional orange peel adds brightness.

The result is a cup that tastes sweet, spiced, and slightly rustic without becoming heavy.

Best Coffee Beans for Café de Olla

For Café de Olla, I like coffee beans that can hold up to spices without disappearing. A very delicate light roast may taste too thin once cinnamon and sugar enter the cup. A very dark, smoky roast can make the drink too bitter. The best choice is usually medium roast or medium-dark roast.

Look for beans with notes like the following:

• Chocolate
• Cocoa
• Brown sugar
• Caramel
• Toasted nuts
• Cinnamon-like warmth
• Mild citrus
• Molasses
• Soft spice

Mexican coffee is the most natural choice because it matches the recipe’s origin and often has gentle, nutty, chocolatey notes. Guatemalan coffee is also excellent because it can bring cocoa, spice, and orange-like brightness. Colombian coffee gives balance. Brazilian coffee makes the drink smoother and nuttier.

A good option from earlier bean guides would be Volcanica Guatemala Antigua if you want chocolate and spice, or Fresh Roasted Colombian Supremo if you want a balanced, easy cup.

Traditional Café de Olla Ingredients

Here is the classic ingredient idea:

• Ground coffee
• Water
• Cinnamon stick
• Piloncillo
• Cloves
• Orange peel, optional
• Star anise, optional

The two most important ingredients are coffee and cinnamon. The third most traditional ingredient is piloncillo, a cone-shaped, unrefined cane sugar commonly used in Mexican cooking. It tastes deeper than white sugar, with molasses, caramel, and brown sugar notes.

If you cannot find piloncillo, use dark brown sugar. It will not be the same, but it gives a similar warmth.

Easy Café de Olla Recipe at Home

Ingredients

For about 2 generous cups:

• 2 cups water
• 2 tablespoons medium-ground coffee
• 1 cinnamon stick
• 2 to 3 tablespoons grated piloncillo or dark brown sugar
• 2 whole cloves, optional
• 1 small strip of orange peel, optional
• 1 small star anise, optional

Instructions

1. Add water, cinnamon stick, piloncillo, cloves, orange peel, and star anise to a small saucepan.
2. Bring to a gentle simmer over medium heat.
3. Stir until the piloncillo dissolves.
4. Reduce the heat and simmer for 5 minutes so the spices infuse the water.
5. Turn off the heat.
6. Add the ground coffee and stir gently.
7. Cover and steep for 4 to 5 minutes.
8. Strain through a fine mesh strainer, cloth filter, or paper filter.
9. Serve hot in mugs.

The key is not to boil the coffee aggressively after adding the grounds. Simmer the spices first, then steep the coffee off the heat. This keeps the cup smoother and less bitter.

Quick Café de Olla Recipe Table

How Sweet Should Café de Olla Be?

Café de Olla is usually sweetened, but it should not taste like syrup. The sweetness should support the cinnamon and coffee, not cover them. I like starting with 2 tablespoons of piloncillo for 2 cups of water, then adjusting from there.

Use less sweetener if:

• Your coffee is naturally chocolatey or sweet.
• You drink coffee black.
• You want a more bitter-spiced cup.
• You plan to serve it with dessert.

Use more sweetener if:

• Your coffee is dark and bitter.
• You want a dessert-style cup.
• You are serving it with milk.
• You want a more traditional sweet profile.

Piloncillo gives the best flavor because it has depth. White sugar sweetens, but it does not add the same molasses warmth. Dark brown sugar is the easiest substitute.

Can You Make Café de Olla Without Piloncillo?

Yes. Piloncillo is traditional, but you can still make a delicious Café de Olla without it.

Good substitutes include:

• Dark brown sugar
• Muscovado sugar
• Demerara sugar
• Turbinado sugar
• Molasses plus brown sugar
• Maple syrup, for a nontraditional version

Dark brown sugar is the closest easy substitute because it has molasses notes. If using maple syrup, add it after brewing so the flavor stays cleaner.

I would avoid plain white sugar unless that is all you have. It sweetens the drink, but the flavor becomes less deep.

Should You Use Ground Cinnamon or Cinnamon Sticks?

Cinnamon sticks are better for Café de Olla. They infuse the water gently and give a cleaner flavor. Ground cinnamon can work in a pinch, but it may make the drink cloudy or gritty.

If using ground cinnamon, start small:

• ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon for 2 cups of water

Add it while simmering the sweetener and spices, then strain well. But if you can get cinnamon sticks, use them. They make the recipe feel more traditional and more polished.

Mexican cinnamon, often called canela, is especially lovely because it tends to be softer and more fragrant than the hard cassia cinnamon many people use.

Best Grind Size for Café de Olla

Use a medium grind, similar to drip coffee. Since the coffee steeps in hot spiced water and is then strained, you do not want it too fine. Fine grounds may create bitterness and sediment. Too coarse, and the coffee may taste weak.

A medium grind gives enough extraction in about 4 to 5 minutes.

If your Café de Olla tastes weak, use slightly more coffee or steep a little longer. If it tastes bitter, use a coarser grind or steep for less time. If it tastes gritty, improve straining or use a paper filter.

Can You Make Café de Olla with Brewed Coffee?

Yes, but the flavor is better when the coffee steeps with the spiced water. If you already have brewed coffee, you can make a quick version.

Quick-Brewed Coffee Version

1. Add 2 cups of brewed coffee to a saucepan.
2. Add 1 cinnamon stick, 2 tablespoons piloncillo or brown sugar, and 1 clove.
3. Warm gently for 5 minutes.
4. Do not boil hard.
5. Strain and serve.

This version is easier but slightly less integrated. The traditional-style method tastes deeper because the spices and coffee come together from the beginning.

Can You Add Milk to Café de Olla?

Traditionally, Café de Olla is often served black, but you can absolutely add milk if you like. Milk turns it into a softer, creamier drink. Whole milk, evaporated milk, oat milk, and almond milk can all work.

Milk pairs especially well when the coffee is medium-dark and the spice level is strong. If adding milk, I recommend making the coffee slightly stronger and sweeter so it does not taste diluted.

Good milk options:

• Whole milk for richness
• Evaporated milk for a dessert-like cup
• Oat milk for creamy sweetness
• Almond milk for a lighter, nutty cup

Add milk after straining, not while simmering the spices and coffee.

Iced Café de Olla

Café de Olla also works beautifully iced. The cinnamon and piloncillo flavor becomes smooth and refreshing over ice.

To make iced café de olla:

1. Brew the recipe as usual.
2. Let it cool to room temperature.
3. Chill in the refrigerator.
4. Serve over ice.
5. Add milk if desired.

For iced Café de Olla, brew slightly stronger because ice will dilute the drink. You can use 2½ to 3 tablespoons of coffee for 2 cups of water if you want a bolder iced version.

A splash of oat milk or evaporated milk makes it especially good.

Strong Café de Olla Version

If you want a stronger cup, do not just boil the coffee longer. That can make it bitter. Instead, increase the coffee amount.

For a stronger recipe:

• 2 cups water
• 3 tablespoons of coffee
• 1 cinnamon stick
• 2 to 3 tablespoons piloncillo
• 2 cloves
• Orange peel, optional

Keep the coffee steep time around 4 minutes. Stronger coffee should come from more coffee, not harsh extraction.

This version is excellent if you plan to add milk or serve it over ice.

Smooth Café de Olla Version

If you want a smoother version, choose a medium-roast coffee and reduce the cloves. Cloves are powerful and can make the drink taste medicinal if overused.

For a smoother recipe:

• Use medium roast coffee.
• Use 1 cinnamon stick.
• Use only 1 clove or skip cloves.
• Use a small strip of orange peel.
• Steep the coffee off the heat.
• Strain through paper if you want a cleaner cup.

A Brazilian, Colombian, Mexican, or Guatemalan medium roast works beautifully here.

Smooth Café de Olla should taste warm and sweet, not sharp or smoky.

Common Café de Olla Mistakes

The first mistake is boiling the coffee grounds too hard. This can make the cup harsh and bitter. Simmer the spices first, then steep the coffee off the heat.

The second mistake is using too much clove. Clove is strong. Two whole cloves are enough for a small batch.

The third mistake is using too much orange peel. A little peel adds brightness, but too much white pith can add bitterness.

The fourth mistake is using very dark, smoky coffee. The spices and sugar already bring intensity, so a burnt roast can become too heavy.

The fifth mistake is not straining well. Café de olla should feel rustic but not gritty.

The sixth mistake is using plain white sugar and expecting the same flavor as piloncillo. It will sweeten the drink, but it will not add the same depth.

What to Serve with Café de Olla

Café de Olla is wonderful with simple baked goods and breakfast foods. It pairs especially well with:

• Pan dulce
• Conchas
• Churros
• Cinnamon rolls
• Buttered toast
• Chocolate cake
• Flan
• Tres leches cake
• Sweet bread
• Breakfast pastries

Because the drink already has cinnamon and sweetness, it pairs best with warm, simple, bakery-style flavors. It also works beautifully as an after-dinner coffee.

My Favorite Home Version

My favorite home version is simple: medium-roast coffee, a cinnamon stick, piloncillo, one clove, and a small strip of orange peel. I do not like overpowering the coffee with too many spices. The best Café de Olla should still taste like coffee, not just cinnamon.

For two cups, I like:

• 2 cups water
• 2½ tablespoons medium-ground coffee
• 1 cinnamon stick
• 2 tablespoons piloncillo
• 1 clove
• Small orange peel strip

I simmer the spice water first, turn off the heat, steep the coffee for 4 minutes, and then strain. That gives me a cup that is sweet, spiced, smooth, and still coffee-forward.

Final Thoughts: Café de Olla Is Simple, Cozy, and Full of Character

Café de Olla is one of the easiest traditional coffee recipes to make at home because it does not require expensive equipment. You only need coffee, water, cinnamon, piloncillo or brown sugar, and a small saucepan. Optional spices like cloves, star anise, and orange peel can make it more aromatic, but the core recipe stays simple.

The most important tips are to use a good medium or medium-dark coffee, simmer the spices before adding the grounds, avoid boiling the coffee aggressively, and strain well before serving. Once you understand the base recipe, you can adjust sweetness, strength, spice, and milk to match your taste.

It is a beautiful recipe for slow mornings, cold evenings, holiday breakfasts, after-dinner coffee, or any time you want your kitchen to smell like cinnamon, caramel, and fresh coffee.

FAQ: Café de Olla Recipe at Home

What is Café de Olla?

Café de Olla is a traditional Mexican spiced coffee made with coffee, cinnamon, piloncillo, and water. Some versions also include cloves, orange peel, or star anise.

Do I need a clay pot to make Café de Olla?

No. A clay pot is traditional, but a small saucepan works perfectly at home.

What can I use instead of piloncillo?

Dark brown sugar is the easiest substitute. Muscovado sugar, demerara sugar, turbinado sugar, or a little molasses mixed with brown sugar can also work.

What coffee is best for Café de Olla?

Medium or medium-dark coffee works best. Mexican, Colombian, Guatemalan, and Brazilian beans are good choices because they bring chocolate, caramel, nutty, and warm spice-friendly notes.

Can I use instant coffee?

You can, but it will not taste as rich. If using instant coffee, simmer the spices and sweetener first, then stir in instant coffee after turning off the heat.

Can I make Café de Olla without cloves?

Yes. Cinnamon and piloncillo are the most important ingredients. Cloves are optional.

Can Café de Olla be served iced?

Yes. Brew it slightly stronger, chill it, then serve over ice. Add milk if desired.

Can I add milk to Café de Olla?

Yes. Traditional versions are often served black, but milk, evaporated milk, oat milk, or almond milk can all be added after straining.

Why is my Café de Olla bitter?

It may be bitter because the coffee was boiled too hard, steeped too long, ground too fine, or made with a very dark, smoky roast.

How do I make Café de Olla stronger?

Use more coffee instead of boiling for longer. For 2 cups of water, use 2½ to 3 tablespoons of coffee for a stronger cup.