OneHundredCoffee is reader-supported, and some products displayed may earn us an affiliate commission. Details
Coffee lovers know how dramatically brewing methods can affect the taste and experience of the same coffee beans. Intrigued by this, we decided to brew identical beans using five popular methods—French Press, Pour-Over, Aeropress, Moka Pot, and Cold Brew—to find out which method truly delivers the best flavor.
Our Test Setup
We started with freshly roasted, single-origin Arabica beans from Ethiopia, known for their bright acidity, fruity notes, and smooth finish. Each brewing method used a standardized grind appropriate for its technique, maintaining consistent water temperature and ratios.
Elegant French Press with stainless filtration and heat-resistant glass. Brews bold, rich coffee in minutes with no mess.
Price on Amazon
Reusable stainless steel filter with borosilicate glass. Control every pour for smooth, balanced, and flavorful coffee anytime.
Price on Amazon
Fast and portable coffee press with low bitterness and no grit. Ideal for home, travel, or camp brewing adventures.
Price on Amazon
Classic Italian moka pot for rich stovetop espresso. Sleek design and easy pour spout for mess-free brewing.
Price on Amazon
Cold brew made easy with this airtight, BPA-free coffee maker. Smooth taste and perfect for fridge storage.
Price on Amazon1. French Press
Taste Profile: Bold, robust, full-bodied.
Brewing the coffee in a French press created a rich, full-bodied coffee. The immersion method brought out deep chocolate and earthy undertones but slightly muted the fruity brightness of our Ethiopian beans.
Verdict: Perfect for those who prefer intense, robust coffees.
2. Pour-Over
Taste Profile: Clean, bright, balanced.
The pour-over method highlighted the beans’ complex fruity notes beautifully, offering a delicate balance between acidity and sweetness. Its clear and nuanced flavors made every sip enjoyable.
Verdict: Ideal for coffee enthusiasts who appreciate clarity and complexity.
3. Aeropress
Taste Profile: Rich, smooth, and well-rounded.
Aeropress delivered a remarkably smooth and balanced cup. It managed to capture the beans’ fruitiness while also providing a fuller body than pour-over, presenting a harmonious flavor experience.
Verdict: Excellent for versatile drinkers seeking a smooth, consistent cup.
4. Moka Pot
Taste Profile: Strong, espresso-like, slightly bitter.
The moka pot method produced a powerful, concentrated coffee resembling espresso. While the richness was enjoyable, the subtle fruity notes of the Ethiopian beans were somewhat overshadowed by the intensity and slight bitterness.
Verdict: Ideal for espresso lovers or as a base for milk-based coffee drinks.
5. Cold Brew
Taste Profile: Mellow, sweet, low-acid.
Cold brewing offered a surprisingly different take. The extended steeping time resulted in a very smooth, sweet coffee with low acidity. Although the complexity diminished, the resulting beverage was incredibly refreshing and pleasant.
Verdict: Best suited for those sensitive to acidity or preferring a refreshing iced coffee.
Overall Winner
After careful tasting and consideration, the Pour-Over method took the top spot. It beautifully showcased the beans’ nuanced fruity and floral notes while maintaining an ideal balance of acidity and sweetness.
Runner-Up
Close behind was the Aeropress, praised for its smooth, rounded flavor and exceptional ease of use.
Final Thoughts
The best brewing method ultimately depends on personal taste preferences. Whether you prefer bold and robust or delicate and nuanced, experimenting with different brewing methods is a delightful journey every coffee enthusiast should undertake.
